Certainty Is Overrated: The Real Skill Leaders Need in Uncertain Times
Trust during uncertainty isn't about having answers. It's about understanding what people need.
The Pressure to Perform Stability
When markets tighten, forecasts wobble, and headlines shift weekly, leaders feel a quiet but powerful pressure: Be certain.
Boards want clarity. Teams want reassurance. Investors want direction.
But here’s the reality most leaders won’t say out loud:
You don’t always have the answers.
And pretending you do may be the fastest way to erode trust.
The real leadership challenge during economic uncertainty isn’t strategic forecasting. It’s psychological containment, managing fear, maintaining alignment, and sustaining performance when ambiguity is unavoidable.
The question isn’t “How do I eliminate uncertainty?”
It’s “How do I build trust when certainty isn’t available?”
That’s where a psychometric and behavioral lens gives leaders a strategic edge most don’t realize they’re missing.
Why Uncertainty Hijacks Performance
Uncertainty activates the brain’s threat system.
When outcomes feel unpredictable, the amygdala signals danger. Cognitive bandwidth narrows. Creativity drops. Collaboration weakens. People conserve energy and protect themselves.
But here’s the overlooked truth: Uncertainty is not experienced uniformly. It’s filtered through hardwired behavioral drives.
A leader announces a restructuring.
One employee sees opportunity.
Another hears instability.
A third feels emotionally flooded.
A fourth just wants a clear next step.
Same message. Completely different internal reactions.
Why?
Because people are wired differently.
- Those with a strong need for stability experience ambiguity as physiological stress.
- Those with high emotional depth carry uncertainty longer and more intensely.
- Those wired for urgency disengage if action stalls.
- Those driven by consensus distrust decisions made without input.
This isn’t resilience. It’s wiring.
And most leaders communicate through their own lens, assuming what reassures them will reassure others.
That assumption is where trust begins to fracture.
What Doesn’t Work: The Confidence Performance
In uncertain environments, leaders typically default to one of two responses:
Over-project confidence.
Bold messaging. Decisive tone. Future-focused optimism.
Or:
Go quiet.
Wait for more information. Avoid premature communication.
Both approaches backfire.
Research on organizational trust consistently shows that employees don’t expect omniscience. They expect alignment between message and reality.
When leaders manufacture confidence that doesn’t match lived experience, employees experience cognitive dissonance. Something feels off. Trust weakens.
Silence is equally damaging. In the absence of information, the brain fills gaps with threat-based assumptions. Anxiety spreads faster than facts.
The issue isn’t whether you have answers.
It’s whether your behavior aligns with your team’s psychological expectations of trustworthy leadership.
Trust Isn’t Universal - It’s Attribute-Driven
Trust can be defined simply: Trust is the belief that someone will meet your expectations.
Those expectations cluster around three dimensions:
- Character (Will they do what they say?)
- Competence (Can they deliver?)
- Compassion (Do they care about me?)
Here’s the strategic insight:
What counts as trustworthy behavior differs by person.
- An employee wired for structure expects predictability and consistent updates.
- An employee wired for precision expects data and honesty about unknowns.
- An employee wired for connection expects emotional acknowledgment.
- An employee wired for autonomy expects decisive action.
When leaders don’t understand these differences, they unintentionally violate expectations.
And trust erodes, not because the strategy is wrong, but because the delivery mismatches the wiring.
Psychometric insight gives leaders something rare:
Clarity about what their team actually needs to feel stable, even when the environment isn’t.
What This Looks Like in Practice
Consider a CFO leading through cost reductions.
She doesn’t have final numbers yet. Timelines are shifting weekly.
Instead of defaulting to generic reassurance, she uses behavioral insight about her team:
- For employees who need stability, she establishes a fixed weekly update cadence, even if the update is, “We’re still evaluating.”
- For detail-oriented team members, she clearly separates facts from speculation and outlines decision criteria.
- For emotionally attuned employees, she schedules small-group discussions to acknowledge the stress openly.
- For urgency-driven team members, she assigns forward-moving initiatives unaffected by the cuts, preserving momentum.
Same situation. Different delivery.
The result?
Turnover slows. Engagement stabilizes. Rumors decrease.
Not because uncertainty disappeared.
Because leadership precision increased.
The Alternative That Works: Emotional Intelligence Anchored in Data
Emotional intelligence during uncertainty isn’t about being softer.
It’s about being accurate.
Psychometric data allows leaders to anticipate:
- Who will need repetition to feel secure.
- Who will disengage without visible action.
- Who will internalize stress quietly.
- Who will distrust top-down decisions.
This transforms communication from reactive to intentional.
Instead of hoping your message lands, you design it to land.
That’s the strategic advantage.
Five Actions Leaders Can Take Immediately
1. Identify Your Own Default Under Stress
Do you over-communicate optimism? Withdraw until certain? Accelerate decisions? Seek consensus? Your stress response sets the tone. Awareness prevents overcorrection.
2. Anchor Communication in What Is Stable
Name what isn’t changing. Roles. Values. Timelines for updates. Stability signals calm the threat response, especially for structure-driven employees.
3. Separate Facts From Interpretation
Detail-driven team members lose trust when leaders blur certainty with speculation. Clarity builds credibility.
4. Diversify Communication Channels
Some employees need relational dialogue. Others prefer written clarity. One all-hands email won’t reach everyone.
5. Lead With Acknowledgment Before Direction
In high-stress environments, compassion restores trust before competence does. A simple “I know this is difficult” activates safety more effectively than polished strategy slides.
The Strategic Payoff
Uncertainty is inevitable.
Trust erosion is not.
Leaders who understand behavioral drivers during volatility:
- Retain critical talent.
- Reduce productivity drag caused by anxiety.
- Accelerate post-crisis alignment.
- Prevent cultural fragmentation.
They stop trying to be certain.
They start being precise.
And that shift, from projecting stability to understanding psychology, creates something powerful:
A team that stays engaged not because the future is clear…
…but because leadership is.
That’s not a soft skill. That’s a structural advantage.
You may also like
The Universal Pattern of Learning
Every skill we master follows the same four-stage pattern. Understanding these stages doesn't just help us learn – it helps us become better teachers and leaders. Let's break it down:
Stage 1: Unconsciously Incompetent
This is where we start: completely unaware of what we don't know. My son watching me drive from the passenger seat thinks it looks easy. Just like I once thought leadership was simply about telling people what to do. In this stage, we don't even know enough to be nervous.
What it sounds like:
- "How hard can it be?"
- "I've watched others do this plenty of times"
- "It's just common sense, right?"
Stage 2: Consciously Incompetent
Reality hits. For my son, it's the moment he first sits behind the wheel and realizes he needs to simultaneously:
- Watch all mirrors
- Control the pedals
- Stay in lane
- Monitor speed
- Watch for hazards
- Follow traffic rules
Suddenly, what looked simple becomes overwhelming. This is exactly how I felt in my first leadership role. The sheer number of things to track, decisions to make, and relationships to manage felt paralyzing.
This is where most people quit. The gap between where they are and where they need to be feels too vast. The awareness of everything they don't know becomes overwhelming.
Stage 3: Consciously Competent
This is the practice phase. Every action requires intense focus and deliberate thought. New drivers white-knuckle the steering wheel, mentally checking every mirror, hyper-aware of every move. New leaders similarly overthink every interaction, decision, and meeting.But here's the good news: with enough practice, patterns emerge. Confidence builds. What once required intense concentration starts to flow more naturally.
Stage 4: Unconsciously Competent
Finally, mastery (auto-pilot)! Experienced drivers navigate complex situations without conscious thought. Their mind is free to focus on higher-level decisions because the basics have become automatic.Great leaders reach this same state. They can seamlessly shift from strategic planning to team development to crisis management, all while making it look effortless. But remember – it only looks effortless because of the thousands of hours of practice that came before.And also remember – never stop learning. Don’t assume you’ve got it figured out.
Breaking Through the Barrier
Remember that critical second stage where most people quit? Here's how to push through:
- Normalize the Overwhelm
- Recognize that feeling overwhelmed is a sign of growth
- Understand that everyone goes through this phase
- Use it as a signal that you're actually learning
- Chunk It Down
- Break the skill into smaller, manageable pieces
- Focus on mastering one element at a time
- Celebrate small wins along the way
- Find a Guide
- Learn from those who've already mastered the skill
- Seek feedback from experienced mentors
- Use structured learning programs to fast-track progress
The Leadership Connection
Leadership development follows this exact pattern. New leaders often move from:
- Thinking leadership is simple (Stage 1)
- Becoming overwhelmed by its complexity (Stage 2)
- Deliberately practicing new skills (Stage 3)
- Finally leading naturally and effectively (Stage 4)
The key is recognizing where you are in the journey and not getting discouraged in that critical second stage. Remember: feeling overwhelmed isn't a sign that you're failing – it's a sign that you're growing.
Moving Forward
Whether you're learning to drive, lead, or master any new skill, understanding these four stages helps you:
- Recognize where you are in the learning journey
- Stay motivated during the challenging phases
- Support others through their own development
- Build more effective learning environments
The path from unconscious incompetence to unconscious competence isn't easy, but it is predictable. And with the right understanding, support, and persistence, it's absolutely achievable.
Have you ever felt like everything in your life burned to ashes, forcing you to rebuild from nothing? That's exactly where I found myself several years ago—staring at the tattoo of a phoenix spreading across my chest, a permanent reminder of my personal cycle of destruction and rebirth.
But in that particular season of rebuilding, something profound happened. I discovered that the most powerful transformation doesn't come from changing your circumstances; it comes from changing how you understand yourself.
The Self-Awareness Delusion
Here's a startling truth: 90% of people believe they're self-aware, but only 10-15% actually are.
This massive gap isn't just interesting—it's dangerous, especially for leaders. When you lack true self-awareness, you're essentially navigating your life and career with a broken compass, convinced you're heading north while actually moving south.
True self-awareness isn't what most people think it is. It's not just acknowledging your strengths and weaknesses or recognizing when you're stressed. It's a much deeper, more nuanced understanding that operates on three distinct levels.
The Phoenix Framework: Three Levels of Self-Awareness
After years of working with executives and building businesses, I've developed what I call the Phoenix Framework—a three-level approach to achieving genuine self-awareness that can transform both your leadership and your life.
Level 1: Data - Knowing Your Behaviors
Most people stop here, mistaking it for complete self-awareness. This level involves recognizing your behavioral patterns:
- How you typically react in meetings
- Your communication style
- Your decision-making approach
- Your habits under pressure
This knowledge is valuable but limited. It tells you what you do, but not why it matters or what drives it.
Think of a leader who recognizes they tend to dominate conversations. They might work on talking less, but without deeper understanding, they'll likely replace one surface behavior with another without addressing the underlying dynamics.
Level 2: Impact - Recognizing Your Effect
This is where self-awareness begins to have real power. Understanding the ripple effects of your behaviors changes everything.
At this level, you recognize:
- How your actions affect others
- The unintended consequences of your communication style
- The organizational impacts of your leadership approach
- The emotional responses you trigger in different situations
When that same leader who dominates conversations understands that their behavior makes team members feel undervalued and less likely to share critical information, they're motivated to change in a way that simple behavioral awareness never could achieve.
Impact awareness transforms leadership because it connects behaviors to consequences. It's the difference between knowing you interrupt people and understanding that your interruptions are silencing the voices you most need to hear.
Level 3: Drives - Uncovering Your Core Motivations
This is the deepest and most transformative level of self-awareness. Here, you understand the innate drives and motivations that fuel your behaviors:
- What are your fundamental needs?
- What gives you energy versus what drains you?
- What hardwired tendencies shape your natural approach?
- What are you unconsciously seeking or avoiding?
Our dominating leader might discover they have a high drive for influence—a natural need to shape outcomes and direct conversations. This insight is powerful because it reveals that their need isn't wrong; it's just being expressed in a counterproductive way.
With an awareness of their drive, they can find healthier ways to satisfy that influence need—perhaps by focusing on asking powerful questions or by channeling their energy into strategic planning sessions where directive input is more valuable.
Why All Three Levels Matter
Each level of the Phoenix Framework builds on the previous one, creating a comprehensive understanding that transforms how you lead and live:
Data alone leads to surface-level behavioral tweaks that rarely stick.
Data + Impact creates meaningful motivation for change but may lead to suppressing natural drives rather than channeling them effectively.
Data + Impact + Drives allows for authentic transformation by helping you satisfy your core needs in ways that create positive rather than negative impact.
Rising From Your Own Ashes
The phoenix doesn't just rebuild itself identically after burning—it emerges as something new and more powerful. True self-awareness works the same way.
When you understand not just your behaviors but their impact and the drives behind them, you don't simply become a "better version" of yourself. You transform into something fundamentally more effective and authentic.
For me, that tattoo across my chest became more than just a symbol of surviving difficult times. It became a daily reminder of the continuous cycle of self-discovery and reinvention that powers genuine growth.
The most profound leadership tool isn't found in business books or management theories. It's found in the mirror—but only when you know how to look beyond the surface to see the complete picture of who you are, how you affect others, and what truly drives you forward.
Are you ready to rise from the ashes of self-unawareness?
The Resume Relic
Let's face it: resumes are relics. They're snapshots of past experiences and skills, often carefully curated and increasingly unreliable in the age of AI-generated content. Even if we could guarantee their authenticity, two critical questions emerge:
- Can resumes reliably tell us about a candidate's skills and experience in today's rapidly evolving job market?
- Are skills and experience even among the top things we should be looking for in a candidate?
The truth is, the resume-centric approach to hiring was never foolproof. It became the standard because, for a long time, it was the best option we had. But in today's dynamic business landscape, it's time to look beyond the paper and focus on factors that truly predict success.
The Top 10 Factors More Important Than Skills & Experience
Here are ten factors that might be more predictive of a candidate's success than their listed skills and experience:
1. Hardwiring and Innate Drivers
Understanding a person's core motivations and natural tendencies can provide invaluable insights into how they'll perform in a role and within a team. Tools like Aptive Index can help uncover these crucial attributes. These innate characteristics often determine how effectively someone will apply their skills and experience.
2. Adaptability and Learning Agility
In a rapidly changing business environment, the ability to adapt quickly and learn new skills is often more valuable than existing knowledge. A candidate who can pivot quickly and absorb new information will outperform one with a static skill set.
3. Culture Fit and Values Alignment
How well does a candidate's personal values and work style align with your organization's culture and mission? This alignment can significantly impact their job satisfaction, productivity, and longevity with your company.
4. Emotional Intelligence (EQ)
Self-awareness, self-regulation, motivation, empathy, and social skills are crucial for effective collaboration and leadership. High EQ often translates to better team dynamics and customer relationships.
5. Problem-Solving Approach
How a candidate approaches complex problems can reveal more about their potential than their current skill set. Look for creative thinking, analytical skills, and the ability to break down complex issues.6. Resilience and GritThe capacity to persist in the face of challenges and bounce back from setbacks is a strong indicator of long-term success. This trait often separates high performers from the rest.
7. Potential for Growth
Assessing a candidate's capacity and desire for development can be more valuable than their current skills. Look for curiosity, eagerness to learn, and a history of personal and professional growth.
8. Collaboration and Teamwork Skills
The ability to work effectively with others and contribute to a positive team dynamic is crucial in most modern workplaces. These skills often determine how well a person can apply their individual abilities within a team context.
9. Alignment with Future Organizational Needs
Consider how well a candidate's potential aligns with where your organization is heading, not just where it is now. This forward-thinking approach can help future-proof your workforce.
10. Diversity of Thought and Experience
A candidate's unique perspectives can bring valuable diversity to problem-solving and innovation within the organization. This diversity often leads to more creative solutions and better decision-making.
Moving Beyond the Resume
Does this mean we should toss resumes out the window? Not necessarily. They can still provide useful context about a candidate's journey. However, they shouldn't be the primary factor in hiring decisions.Instead, we need to develop more holistic assessment methods that take into account the factors listed above. This might involve:
- Structured interviews that probe for adaptability, problem-solving skills, and cultural fit
- Psychometric assessments to understand a candidate's innate drivers and potential
- Job auditions or simulations to see how candidates perform in real-world scenarios
- Reference checks that focus on a candidate's soft skills and ability to learn and grow
Conclusion
It's time to move beyond the resume and rethink what truly matters in hiring. By focusing on factors like innate drivers, adaptability, and cultural fit, we can make better hiring decisions. This approach not only leads to more successful hires but also opens doors for candidates who might have been overlooked in a traditional resume-centric process.The future of hiring isn't about finding the person with the perfect list of skills and experiences. It's about finding individuals with the right potential, drive, and alignment with your organization's values and goals. By prioritizing these ten factors over traditional skills and experience, you'll be well on your way to building a more dynamic, adaptable, and successful workforce.